---
format: "aidr-story-markdown/v1"
id: "7b8ef2b88b8fb9cc3ea5f8d1e36dcba4799ade91934922e59b38803c7010a77c"
canonical_url: "https://aidr.today/7b8ef2b8?lang=en"
title: "Court: 4th Amendment Doesn't Cover AI-Generated 'Probable Cause'"
lang: "en"
requested_lang: "en"
available_langs: ["en","vi"]
translation_fallback: null
fallback_fields: []
published_at: "2026-11-19T22:56:59.000Z"
category: "Regulation"
topics: ["regulation"]
source_urls: ["https://www.techdirt.com/2026/11/19/court-tells-cops-that-the-4th-amendment-doesnt-cover-ai-generated-probable-cause/","https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50567735"]
summary: "I don’t know where this decision will take us, but its implications reach much further than the single case it covers. AI is pretty much everywhere, and if a court says an algorithm can’t make probable cause determinations, it affects/infects everything from facial recognition tech to predictive policing software to Axon adding AI shovelware to its omnipresent body cameras under the (correct) assumption cops don’t like writing reports. In this case, Alain Osorio was arrested for allegedly passing a bad check at local bank. The only pictures of the suspect came from the bank’s CCTV footage. This was handed over to Detective Ryan Kilmer of the Florence (KY) Police Department. The detective decided to run a screenshot of the suspect’s face (derived from the CCTV footage) through the PD’s facial recognition program. The decision [PDF] doesn’t specify which facial recognition program was used, but given that the match was made using photos found on Facebook, it suggests Clearview AI might have been involved, given its scraping of hundreds of billions of images from the open web since its inception. Not that it did anything useful in terms of actual detective work. Nor did it do anythin…"
---

# Court: 4th Amendment Doesn't Cover AI\-Generated 'Probable Cause'

> [Open the canonical story](<https://aidr.today/7b8ef2b8?lang=en>)

**Published:** 2026-11-19T22:56:59.000Z
**Category:** Regulation
**Topics:** regulation

## Summary

I don’t know where this decision will take us, but its implications reach much further than the single case it covers\. AI is pretty much everywhere, and if a court says an algorithm can’t make probable cause determinations, it affects/infects everything from facial recognition tech to predictive policing software to Axon adding AI shovelware to its omnipresent body cameras under the \(correct\) assumption cops don’t like writing reports\. In this case, Alain Osorio was arrested for allegedly passing a bad check at local bank\. The only pictures of the suspect came from the bank’s CCTV footage\. This was handed over to Detective Ryan Kilmer of the Florence \(KY\) Police Department\. The detective decided to run a screenshot of the suspect’s face \(derived from the CCTV footage\) through the PD’s facial recognition program\. The decision \[PDF\] doesn’t specify which facial recognition program was used, but given that the match was made using photos found on Facebook, it suggests Clearview AI might have been involved, given its scraping of hundreds of billions of images from the open web since its inception\. Not that it did anything useful in terms of actual detective work\. Nor did it do anythin…

## Sources

- [Story source](<https://www.techdirt.com/2026/11/19/court-tells-cops-that-the-4th-amendment-doesnt-cover-ai-generated-probable-cause/>)
- [Discussion](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50567735>)

